A 5-day email sequence that converts: A step-by-step guide

As social platforms get more crowded and algorithms change rapidly, email marketing continues to remain one of the best ways to convert readers into buyers.

But crafting emails that actually drive sales is challenging — part art and part science.

So today I want to teach you how to write a good email sequence with an easy-to-follow example.

For those of you not familiar, an email sequence is a series of pre-written, automated emails you can send to subscribers on your email list. And the purpose of the sequence is to educate, nurture, and guide prospective customers through a decision-making process.

The decision: Should they buy from you or not?

I’m going to break down a 5-day email sequence that should help you get more people saying “Yes!” and fewer saying “no, thank you.”

Let’s dive in.

Outline Of A 5-Day Email Sequence

Day 1: Agitate The Problem

The goal of your first email is to highlight the problem your product solves. But you can’t just shine a spotlight on it. You need to twist the knife to make your reader really “feel” the problem.

We’ll call this current feeling their “negative present.”

This is where agitation comes into play.

• Open with a relatable scenario
• Dive into the pain points and twist the knife
• Hint at a solution (without revealing it yet)

Example opening: "I personally know how hard Facebook ads can be. I used to stay up until 2 AM trying to figure out why mine weren’t converting. Countless hours, tons of frustration, and thousands of dollars down the drain with nothing to show for it. I get it."

Bonus tip: I like to use specific examples and data to make the problem feel real and urgent. (because it is!)

Day 2: Tease Your Solution

Once you’ve agitated the problem and your reader feels their negative present, you can tease out your specific solution to their problem. When you do this, you help your prospect envision their “positive future” — a time when their problem has been solved, thanks to you.

• Briefly recap the problem
• Tease out how it solves the problem
• Introduce your product/service

Example: "What if you could set up high-converting Facebook ads that returned $3.50 for every $1 spent, and you could do it in less than 15 minutes using AI?”

Bonus tip: Focus on benefits, not features. What transformation does your product offer? People care mostly about money and time. If you can tie your transformation to those things, that’s more powerful.

Day 3: Share The Proof

Okay, so on day 2, you teased out your solution. But why should someone buy from you? What’s your secret sauce? Why should they part with their hard-earned money or time? And why now?

Here are some things you can share to help them move through their decision process:

• A case study or success story that looks like them. Include specific, tangible results.
• Overcome the common objections inside of the email

Example: "Take Sarah Gordon, for example. Sarah’s a first-time SaaS founder who was skeptical because she’d already wasted $10,000+ on Facebook ads that weren’t converting. But after working with us, her conversion rates jumped by 237% in just three weeks. Sarah was able to train her marketing manager to create future ads in less than 20 minutes. And now Sarah has a new, profitable channel. Plus, she finally has time to focus on improving her product, while the marketing team brings in new revenue."

Bonus tip: If you can make it happen, include a short video testimonial. Seeing and hearing from real customers that remind us of ourselves is incredibly powerful. Just imagine it — Wouldn’t you love to see and hear Sarah Gordon talking about this herself?

Day 4: Give Them The Details

If you’ve nailed your first three emails, your prospect should be in a good position to hear your offer. They’ll want to know how it works, how much it costs, and how to get started.

So your fourth email needs to do these things:

• Clearly explain what's included
• Highlight your unique selling points (Why you?)
• Introduce your pricing (If it makes sense, frame it as an investment.)

Example:

"For less than $3 per day, you get access to:"

• The AI ad creator which generates ads that convert at $3.50 per every $1 spent, on average.
• The AI image generator, which helps your ads get 271% more click throughs than manually generated Canva images.
• The analytics dashboard that allows you to track your best channels so you can double-down and increase profit (without wasting your time).

Bonus tip: If you offer a guarantee, mention it here to reduce any perceived risk.

Day 5: Go For The Close

You’ve now twisted the knife on their problem, teased our your solution, shared proof that it works, and explained how you’ll make it happen.

On the last day of your email sequence, ask your customers to buy.

So in this last email, you’ll want to:

• Recap the main benefits
• Introduce a time-limited discount (optional)
• Provide a clear call-to-action to move forward.

Example: "Our launch price ends tonight at midnight EST. After that, our $90/month option with a 14-day free trial will be $120/month without a trial. There’s never been a better time to start making more money from your Facebook ads. Say “see ya” to countless wasted hours and frustrating results. Click here to take advantage of your discount right now."

Implementing Your 5-day Email Sequence

I know this is a lot of information to digest. And getting your email sequence right can feel like a lot of work. Here are some tips to do this successfully:

1. Write all five emails before you ever start sending. You want to have consistency and cohesion in your messaging.
2. Use compelling subject lines for every email. Aim to pique curiosity and/or highlight benefits. Specify using numbers when it makes sense, and limit subject lines to 55 characters max.
3. Keep your emails short, concise, and to the point. Hubspot found that 150-200 word emails often yield the best results.
4. Include a CTA (call-to-action) in every email, even if it's just "Reply back if you have a question."
5. Personalize wherever possible. If you’re collecting any data on your customers, this is a great time to use it in your messaging. For example, personalize the testimonial in email #3 above by sharing a testimonial from someone exactly like them (I do this using RightMessage).

Closing Your Sequence With A “Why didn’t you?” Email

No matter how good your email sequence is, most people won’t end up purchasing. And you shouldn’t feel bad about that. That’s normal with any kind of marketing.

You might consider waiting a few days after your fifth email, and then following up with a question: Why didn’t you buy?

This can be a short and simple final email, asking if they're still interested. And if not, why not?

You can use a solution like RightMessage to make it as easy as clicking a button to tell you why.

This provides valuable feedback that you can use to make your sequence even better as you analyze and understand the results.

Remember, the key to a successful email sequence is to focus on the customer's journey. Every email should move them closer to realizing that your product or service is the solution they've been looking for. And if it isn’t the right fit, your sequence should help them understand that too.

Now it’s time to start building your high-converting email sequence.

I hope you’ll follow this outline to make your writing process smoother and faster. And I hope you’ll have a little fun doing it as well. Because emails don’t have to be stuffy and serious all the time.

So don’t be afraid to be casual and conversational, if appropriate. I personally enjoy emails that read like someone is just sharing advice over a beer. You can consider this approach if your subject matter allows for it.

And if you want to dive deeper into email marketing strategies like this one, check out my flagship course, The Creator MBA. It's packed with 19 hours of strategies and tactics to help you turn social media followers and email subscribers into customers.

And that’s all for today.

See you next week.